Very Reverend John DeRose
1870 - 1873
Most Reverend Denis M. Bradley
1873 - 1880
Very Reverend John W. Murphy
1880 - 1882
Very Reverend Timothy P. Linehan
1882 - 1890
Right Reverend Monsignor Michael C. McDonough
1890 - 1899
Very Reverend Denis J. O'Brien
1899 - 1904
Very Reverend Michael F. Drain
1904 - 1907
Very Reverend Martin A. Clary
1907 - 1913
Very Reverend Timothy H. Houlihan
1913 - 1922
Right Reverend Monsignor George P. Johnson
1922 - 1942
Reverend Monsignor Edward F. Ward
1942 - 1950
Reverend Monsignor William G. Cunneen
1950 - 1964
Reverend Monsignor Paul D. Gleason
1964 - 1971
Reverend Monsignor Leopold G. Nicknair
1971 - 1977
Very Reverend Joseph W. Whitlock
1977 - 1980
Very Reverend Albin A. Andrus
1980 - 1983
Reverend Monsignor Michael J. Henchal
1983 - 1988
Very Reverend Paul A. Plante
1988 - 1993
Very Reverend James L. Nadeau
1993 - 2005
Reverend Monsignor Paul F. Stefanko
2005 - 2009
Very Reverend Louis J. Phillips
2009 - 2014
Very Reverend Claude R. Gendreau
2014 - 2016
Very Reverend Gregory P. Dube
2016 - 2021
Very Reverend Seamus Griesbach
2021 - Present